Judges' Public Council deems Judge Ruslan Arsiryi dishonest for attempting to block qualification assessment

Judges' Public Council deems Judge Ruslan Arsiryi dishonest for attempting to block qualification assessment
Judges' Public Council deems Judge Ruslan Arsiryi dishonest for attempting to block qualification assessment

Conclusion on professional ethics violations

The Judges' Public Council (JPC) decided to recognise Ruslan Arsiryi, who held the position of judge at the liquidated Kyiv District Administrative Court (OASK), as a person who does not meet the criteria of integrity and professional ethics. This conclusion is based on dossier materials and the ruling of the First Disciplinary Chamber of the High Council of Justice (HCJ) dated 2 June 2025, No. 1163/1dp/15-25.

Attempts to evade qualification assessment

According to investigation data, in 2019, Arsiryi discussed methods of countering the qualification assessment with colleagues. Specifically, they discussed obtaining sick leave certificates without valid grounds and filing lawsuits against members of the High Qualification and Disciplinary Commission of Judges (VQJC).

On 3 April 2019, the necessity of obtaining sick leave certificates was discussed in the judge's presence. On 7 March of the same year, Pavlo Vovk advised Arsiryi to avoid visits to the VQJC, citing illness. On 12 April, Arsiryi himself proposed sending a clarifying letter to the commission requesting the postponement of the assessment. Subsequently, he failed to appear for the exams twice — on 17 April and 21 May — justifying his absence with incapacity for work.

The investigation revealed inconsistencies in the judge's actions: two days before the first exam, he issued seven rulings, and on the days he claimed to be undergoing inpatient treatment (20 and 22 May), he participated in conversations in Vovk's office. Arsiryi agreed with colleagues on 29 May regarding the version that the original sick leave certificate had been seized by the State Bureau of Investigation, and on 3 June, he used precisely this argumentation in his application to the VQJC.

Blocking assessment through court lawsuits

According to the National Anti-Corruption Bureau (NABU), Pavlo Vovk organised the filing of lawsuits against VQJC members with the aim of creating a conflict of interest and blocking the assessment process. Arsiryi opened proceedings in case No. 640/4634/19 based on a lawsuit by Oleh Holovenko, combined it with Anna Panova's lawsuit and other cases (including Igor Shulman's), following Vovk's instructions to concentrate proceedings under his jurisdiction.

By May 2019, detailed draft rulings in favour of the plaintiffs already existed, yet the case was not resolved on the merits for over 3.5 years. The HCJ Disciplinary Chamber opened a case regarding the delay in review on 21 May 2025. The JPC views such actions as the use of judicial powers to block the assessment in their own interests and those of their colleagues.

Attempts to influence Supreme Court judges

On 3 June 2019, following a ruling by the Supreme Court's Cassation Administrative Court (CAS) requiring VQJC members to continue working, methods of influencing the panel judges — Raisa Khanova and Tetiana Shypulina — were discussed in Vovk's office with Arsiryi's participation. Arsiryi proposed using personal connections to contact Shypulina for the purpose of "intimidation" ("будем пугать" [we will scare]) and outlined a procedural mechanism to limit the effect of the ruling. The authenticity of these conversations has been confirmed by NABU expert examinations.

Influence on VQJC composition and dismissal of commission members

Arsiryi participated in discussions regarding candidates for the VQJC, focusing on their expected loyalty to Vovk (specifically, he proposed Olena Zhuravska and others). He also conveyed instructions on changing the grounds for the dismissal of VQJC member Taras Lukash — from a violation of incompatibility rules to voluntary resignation, in order to avoid the publication of the initial order by the head of the State Judicial Administration.

Extra-judicial influence on case reviews

Documentation records episodes of discussions with Vovk regarding the securing of a lawsuit and the explanation of a ruling concerning the competition for the head of the state enterprise "Information Judicial Systems", as well as the preparation of draft rulings in the cases of Valentyn Marchuk and prosecutor Volodymyr Bedrykivskyi. NABU lists these proceedings among those where Arsiryi issued rulings in execution of instructions from OASK management. Separately, mediation in the interests of Artur Yemelyanov (a request regarding his ex-wife's case) is described.

Violations of property declaration rules

Instances of incomplete declaration were identified: a 65.7 m² estate in Ivankivychi was declared instead of a significantly larger object with a chapel; the value of a BMW X5 was understated (50,000 UAH in the declaration versus 1.1 million UAH in registration documents); income from the sale of a Toyota RAV4 was not declared. Doubts also arose regarding the sources of an inheritance exceeding 9 million UAH and the financing of his son's 109.3 m² apartment.

Other recorded violations

  • Issuing rulings while abroad or on leave (specifically, rulings dated 15 January 2013 and 9 March 2022).
  • Signs of academic dishonesty in his 2019 candidate dissertation (reproduction of fragments without proper citation).
  • Review of a case based on a lawsuit by Boryslav Rosenblat regarding NABU's actions in the "amber case", exceeding the limits of administrative jurisdiction.
  • Insufficient justification of rulings (ban on renaming Vatutin Avenue, cancellation of JPC conclusions, Andriy Portnov's lawsuit regarding textbooks).

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

Leave a comment

Links are not allowed in comments. The editors may remove comments without explanation.
Back to top ↑