Judge expresses disappointment in MP's actions
The presiding judge sharply criticised Serhiy Kuzminykh, a member of parliament from the "Servant of the People" party, during the hearing for his intention to deliver a final statement of 400 pages. The court concluded that the debates and the defendant's final statement are aimed not at achieving the goals of the criminal proceedings, but at delaying the trial.
«Мені соромно за вас, Сергію Володимировичу, як за народного обранця. Мені соромно за захисників, яким держава видала мандат на такі дії. Мені соромно за державу в особі суду, яка не виробила ефективного механізму протидії таким зловживанням. Мені соромно за себе особисто» (I am ashamed of you, Serhiy Volodymyrovych, as a people's representative. I am ashamed of the defenders to whom the state issued a mandate for such actions. I am ashamed of the state, in the person of the court, which has not developed an effective mechanism to counter such abuses. I am ashamed of myself personally), the judge emphasised, addressing the defendant.
Delaying the process affects court operations
The court concluded that the debates and the defendant's final statement are intended not to achieve the objectives of the criminal proceedings, but to stall the process. The volume of the MP's planned speech exceeds that of a standard dissertation or book, indicating an abuse of procedural rights by the defence.
As the judge noted, such behaviour by Kuzminykh and his lawyers undermines citizens' trust in state authorities. Observing similar proceedings, a citizen loses faith in the state's ability to effectively perform its functions. Moreover, the delay in this case has a negative impact on other court proceedings, as the panel is forced to postpone their hearings due to the Kuzminykh case.
Court sets limits for speeches
The court warned that if the MP continues to repeat the same points and drag out his speeches, the presiding judge will remove repetitions and anything irrelevant to the case. If necessary, time limits will be set for the defendant's speech.
«Тому суд пропонує вам зараз продовжити судові дебати. Потім, якщо прокурор вирішить скористатися правом на репліку, будуть репліки, а після цього - останнє слово» (Therefore, the court proposes that you now continue the court debates. Then, if the prosecutor decides to use the right to a reply, there will be replies, and after that – the final statement), the judge emphasised.
Charges in the case
Recall that Serhiy Kuzminykh is charged with receiving a bribe of 558,000 hryvnia. According to the investigation, the MP attempted to influence hospital officials to ensure the victory of a specific company in a tender for the purchase of medical equipment.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!