Ukrainian legislation does not contain provisions that would automatically exempt men from mobilisation after reaching the age of 50 or 55. Currently, the conscription campaign covers liable persons up to the age of 60, provided they are fit for service and have no legal grounds for deferment.
Age is not an obstacle to conscription until 60
The central issue in the case examined by the court was the age limit. The 59-year-old plaintiff attempted to prove that his conscription was illegal, as he should have been removed from military records back in 2012 upon reaching the then-current maximum age for remaining in the reserve.
However, the court did not agree with these arguments. Under current regulations, the maximum age for remaining in the reserve for liable persons of the ranks of private, sergeant, and warrant officer is set at 60 years. Since the man had not reached this age at the time of mobilisation, he remained within the scope of conscription activities, provided he met other legal requirements.
Violation of the medical examination procedure
The decisive factor in the case turned out to be not the age issue, but the quality of the medical examination conducted. During the court hearing, it was established that the military medical commission (MMC) had violated the established procedure for the examination.
Specifically, the plaintiff did not undergo the mandatory examination by a psychiatrist. Additionally, the medical documentation lacked results of electrocardiography (ECG) and other necessary tests. Such incompleteness of the medical record cast doubt on the adequacy of the medical examination conducted and the legality of the decisions made on its basis.
The Dnipropetrovsk District Administrative Court decided to cancel the MMC certificate and the mobilisation order. This precedent demonstrates that compliance with procedural requirements when determining fitness for service is of fundamental importance, regardless of the age of the liable person.
Right to appeal MMC decisions
Liable persons have the right to appeal the commission's conclusions if they believe the examination was conducted with violations or does not reflect their actual state of health. Grounds for filing a lawsuit may include:
- incomplete medical examination;
- absence of results of necessary diagnostic procedures;
- other procedural violations that affect the legality of the conclusion.
At the same time, it is worth noting that mere disagreement with the MMC's decision does not lead to its automatic cancellation. Each case requires a detailed assessment of specific circumstances and available evidence.
Grounds for deferment
Article 23 of the Law of Ukraine "On Mobilisation Preparation and Mobilisation" defines the categories of citizens who may receive a deferment from conscription. Such grounds may be related to health status, family circumstances, the need to care for close relatives, or the presence of a job reservation established by the procedure.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!