Cherkasy City Council decided not to pay for already delivered rehabilitation equipment, as council members considered the purchase suspicious. However, no court has yet confirmed these suspicions; instead, courts at all instances have recognised the debt owed to the supplier. As a result, the city is obliged to make the payment, and the total amount turned out to be higher than the initial contract value.
Causes of the debt
In 2023, Cherkasy City Consultative and Diagnostic Polyclinic signed four contracts with Promed Technologies LLC for the supply of Vizion brand rehabilitation equipment. The total value of the deals was approximately 28.55 million UAH. The medical facility received walking training stations, trainers, and equipment for patient recovery after strokes and injuries. However, the supplier never received payment for the delivered equipment.
Budget constraints and council decision
Former polyclinic director Vladyslav Svyrydenko explains the situation by citing budgetary difficulties. According to him, in 2023, the state took the income tax of military personnel from local budgets, resulting in the development budget being unfulfilled. At that time, "from above," they advised not to return the equipment but to agree with the supplier to postpone payment to the following year. These plans were not realised.
On 1 February 2024, Cherkasy City Council, with 26 votes in favour (none against), returned approximately 28.5 million UAH, which had been allocated for the payment of Vizion equipment, to the reserve fund. Deputy Ruslan Batyr, who initiated this decision, explained that the purchase raised suspicions in him. He cited the fact that the equipment was delivered before payment as the main argument. According to the deputy, the released funds were directed to support the Armed Forces of Ukraine.
Vladyslav Svyrydenko notes that before the vote, city lawyers warned the deputies: in the event of a refusal to pay, they would have to pay approximately 20% more through the courts.
Court rulings in favour of the supplier
Promed Technologies LLC went to court. On 22 April 2025, the Commercial Court of Cherkasy Oblast, in case No. 925/233/24, recovered a debt of 27,554,434.64 UAH and a court fee of 413,316.52 UAH from the polyclinic. On 9 July 2025, the Northern Appellate Commercial Court upheld this decision without changes, and it was subsequently confirmed by the cassation instance.
At the time the decisions were made, the polyclinic's assets had already been transferred to another city facility. On 4 December 2025, the Commercial Court recognised this facility as a party to the enforcement proceedings. The following morning, its bank accounts were blocked. The head of the facility, Mykola Tarasov, reported that 13 million UAH had been frozen, part of which was planned to be used for paying staff salaries.
Because the city did not rush to comply with the final court decision, the enforcement service additionally recovered a 10% enforcement fee. These costs could have been avoided if the debt had been settled on time.
Investigation status and liability
To date, it has not been established whether the price of the equipment was inflated. The publication "18000" concluded that it was mostly Chinese equipment after a rebranding, but this is only a journalistic assessment, not a court decision. Chinese production in itself is not a violation of the law. The former polyclinic director claims that the origin of the equipment was not hidden, and the choice of a cheaper option was made at the request of the Department of Health.
According to Vladyslav Svyrydenko, the investigation checked the equipment and documents but found no violations. We will contact the Bureau of Economic Security to clarify the official status of the proceedings.
Mayor Anatoliy Bondarenko, when asked who in the city controls prices for medical equipment, advised turning to the Department of Health or to the individuals who conducted the purchases. Deputy Ruslan Batyr, responding to a question about the future of the debt, noted that he was serving in the Armed Forces of Ukraine during those years and also directed the query to the department.
Vladyslav Svyrydenko calls this system "collective irresponsibility": decisions are made by vote, and in the end, no one bears personal responsibility for their consequences.
Currently, it is known that the equipment remained in the city, the debt to the supplier was recognised, and court and enforcement fees were added to it. The refusal to pay, which was intended to protect the budget, turned out to be more expensive for it.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!