Distinguishing the functions of satellite systems
US billionaire Elon Musk detailed his position on the use of his company's technologies in the context of an armed conflict in an interview at the DealBook forum organised by The New York Times. He emphasised the fundamental difference between two satellite networks: the commercial Starlink and the state-run Starshield.
“There are two satellite systems. One is Starlink, a commercial satellite system. The other is Starshield. Starshield is controlled by the US government. Any actions involving the use of Starshield depend on the Department of War. Starlink is a commercial system; it is not intended to be used as a weapon,” Musk noted.
Stance on offensive operations
Musk claimed that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is misrepresenting the situation regarding the use of satellite systems. According to the businessman, Kyiv is effectively asking for permission to use commercial Starlink for offensive military actions, which the company has been refusing since the start of the full-scale invasion.
“What Zelenskyy is actually talking about is the desire to use Starlink for offensive military operations. And we have refused to do so, as we have refused since the very beginning of the conflict,” the billionaire explained.
He confirmed that a speed limit of approximately 80 miles per hour (129 km/h) has been set for the civilian network, making it impossible to control strike drones through this infrastructure. Musk emphasised that he does not intend to change these rules, as he considers it wrong to make unilateral decisions that could cost human lives.
“Do not ask me, as a private individual, to make decisions about killings that sometimes result in the deaths of innocent people, not just soldiers. That is not my role. And yet I am constantly pressured to do so,” he added.
According to Musk’s logic, the Starshield system should be used for offensive tasks, and the final say on targeting remains with the US Department of War and, possibly, the President of the United States.
Refuting the Sevastopol incident
Separately, the billionaire responded to accusations of shutting down satellite communications during the preparation of a Ukrainian attack on the Russian fleet in Sevastopol. He called these claims untrue.
“This is complete nonsense. At that moment, Starlink satellite beams were not switched on over Crimea. They were not operating because Russia was under sanctions, and switching them on without permission from the State Department would have been illegal for us,” Musk stated.
Assessment of the causes of the war and moral aspects
Commenting on the causes of the conflict, Musk acknowledged Russia as the aggressor in the context of the invasion but simultaneously accused the US of organising a coup in Kyiv.
“From the perspective of the invasion, Russia is the aggressor. But it is also true that we, Americans, organised a coup to remove the democratically elected pro-Russian President of Ukraine. Without the help of the US State Department and other agencies, this would not have happened. Obviously, that was also an offensive action,” the billionaire claims.
Musk expressed concern that the war has been going on for years, during which thousands of people are dying daily, while the borders remain almost unchanged. He believes that anyone who supports this is either a terrible person or has simply not thought about the issue enough.
“I am truly tormented morally by this conflict, which continues while thousands of young people are sent to die every day, and the borders do not change for years. I think that anyone who supports this is a terrible person or has simply not thought about the issue enough,” he said.
Elon Musk also called for compassion towards both Ukrainian and Russian servicemen, noting that mobilised Russians are forced to risk their lives from drone strikes. He criticises the polarised approach that reduces the war to a confrontation between “good” and “evil”.
“There has been too much of this approach: Ukraine is good, Russia is bad. Anything done against Russians is justified. That is an inhumane and terrible position,” Musk concluded.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!